Carvana’s Accounting Explodes Harder Than Tesla’s Cybertruck 🛻

Carvana’s Accounting Explodes Harder Than Tesla’s Cybertruck 🛻

NEWS
Carvana’s Accounting Explodes Harder Than Tesla’s Cybertruck 🛻 

Source: Giphy

The first trading day of 2025 got off to a rough start, with the NASDAQ and S&P extending their losing streaks to five consecutive sessions and the Dow falling for the fourth straight day. Meanwhile, the Sixth Circuit struck down the FCC’s Net Neutrality rules. On a brighter note, oil prices broke out, reaching $73.31—its highest level since mid-October 2024. 👀

Today’s issue highlights a double whammy: Tesla faces a rough day, and Carvana becomes the latest target of Hindenburg Research. 📰

Here’s the S&P 500 heat map. 5 of 11 sectors closed green, with energy (+1.41%) leading and consumer discretionary (-1.08%) lagging.

Source: Finviz.com

And here are the closing prices: 

S&P 500

5,920

-0.27%

Nasdaq

21,182

-0.21%

Russell 2000

2,249

-0.01%

Dow Jones

42720

-0.36%

Most bullish/bearish symbols on Stocktwits at the close: 📈 $DUO, $TPL, $COHR, $HOOD, $FSLR, 📉 $EDU, $TSLA, $RKT, $GM, and $YUMC

*If you’re a business and want to access this data via our API, email us.

COMPANY NEWS
Fireworks And Fumbles. Tesla’s Drama 🎆 

We’ve got a double dose of Tesla drama. 🚗💣 

First, the EV giant logged its first annual sales drop in over a decade. Then, a rented Cybertruck packed with fireworks exploded in the valet lane of Trump’s Las Vegas hotel.

Sales sank 1.1% in 2024 from the previous year. It’s the first time since 2011 that Tesla’s global vehicle count ended lower. Blame slowing demand, aging models, and discount deals that trimmed margins. Guess the days of unlimited hype and minimal competition are over. 🤷

Meanwhile, a Cybertruck loaded with fireworks erupted in flames outside Trump International Hotel, injuring seven people and killing the individual inside. Authorities are treating the incident as a terrorist attack. However, the attacker may have overlooked the fact that the Tesla truck is essentially a tank—it doesn’t blow up very easily.

Despite the setback, analysts remain optimistic about Tesla’s ambitious vision for AI and autonomous technology. They argue that a temporary slump in sales is insignificant when you’re focused on building the future. 🤖

Tesla’s stock closed the day down 6% today, marking its fifth consecutive session of declines.

COMPANY NEWS
Carvana’s Mystery Loan Buyer? 🎂 

When Hindenburg Research sniffs out corporate nonsense, they don’t just ring a bell—they light a bonfire. This time, their target is Carvana, and they’ve gone deep. 

Why Hindenburg’s Suss 🤔 

  • The “Comeback”
    In 2024, Carvana’s stock soared 284%, supposedly leaving bankruptcy fears behind. Hindenburg calls it an illusion.

  • Father-Son Accounting Act
    CEO Ernie Garcia III’s father, Ernest Garcia II (a convicted felon), sold billions in stock before Carvana’s prior collapse. Now, he’s offloaded another $1.4 billion

  • Lax Underwriting & Subprime Loans
    Former insiders claim Carvana approved nearly everyone, leaving borrowers drowning in debt while bundling subprime loans. Hindenburg compares it to the early-2000s mortgage crisis.

  • Mystery Financing
    With Ally Financial stepping back, a new “unrelated” buyer conveniently emerges—likely Cerberus, led by Carvana board member Dan Quayle.

Shady Related-Party Deals 🥷 

  • DriveTime Connection
    Need to offload warranties or inventory at inflated prices? Sell to Dad’s private dealership. Problem solved.

  • Cooking The Books?
    Hindenburg alleges “aggressive” accounting, mid-tier auditing by Grant Thornton, and potential undisclosed SEC investigations.

Bottom Line 🧾 

  • Hindenburg believes Carvana’s “turnaround” is driven by subprime lending, insider profiteering, and questionable accounting.

  • They’re short on Carvana, predicting shareholders will be left holding the bag while the Garcias walk away billions richer.

Price Reaction? Meh. 🤷 

Our recent poll shows 62% of Stocktwits users expect a sharp decline below $150 in 2025 after this report.

From a price action perspective, that sharp drop wasn’t going to happen today – $CVNA is down just under 2% at the close.

(All claims from Hindenburg Research—always do your own due diligence.)

PRESENTED BY STOCKTWITS
Trades For 2025: Your Edge Starts Here 🎯

Welcome to Daily Rip Live with Shay Boloor, Jordan Lee, and special guest Larry Thompson! Here’s the market roadmap we just dropped:

 Tesla ($TSLA): Is the pullback your AI-driven growth play?
 Meta ($META): What’s next for AR/VR innovation?
 Quantum Computing: Honeywell & IonQ in focus.
 2025 Strategy: Small-caps, semiconductors & AI disruption.
 Santa Rally Miss: What it means for January sentiment.

🎥 Watch Now for actionable insights to position yourself for a volatile yet rewarding year.

STOCKS
Other Noteworthy Pops & Drops 📋️ 

Carvana (-1.87%): Shares fell after a Hindenburg Research report alleged $800 million in undisclosed loan sales and accounting manipulation, turning retail sentiment “extremely bearish.

Cloudflare(+4.51%): Goldman Sachs issued a double upgrade to ‘Buy,’ and raised the price target from $77 to $140, and cited improved sales productivity and new growth opportunities.

Uber (+5.01%): Goldman Sachs added the stock to its US conviction list, citing strong growth potential and profitability, while retail investors shrugged off a downgrade from JMP Securities over autonomous vehicle competition.

Tesla (-5.58%): Shares fell below $400 after Q4 deliveries of 495,570 units missed estimates, with retail sentiment turning bearish ahead of upcoming earnings on January 29.

Interactive Brokers (+3.66%): Daily average revenue trades (DART) surged 66% YoY in December, while client equity grew 33%, fueling bullish retail sentiment and a price target hike from Barclays to $214.

SealsSQ Corp (+40.98%): The stock surged after announcing a satellite-as-a-service model in partnership with WISeSat, offering secure IoT data transmission and automation, fueling strong retail optimism.

STOCKTWITS COMMUNITY INSIGHTS
Share Your Top Trade Ideas For 2025! 🤩 

We recently recapped an amazing 2024 on Stocktwits, but with the calendar now turning to 2025, we want to shift our focus to the future…and you can help!

We’re gathering the community’s top ideas for 2025 and giving out Stocktwits Edge to some of our favorites. Come share your highest conviction plays and see where the Stocktwits community is focusing in the new year. 🤑 

Source: Stocktwits.com

Get In Touch 📬

Follow our social channels for great, real-time content on Stocktwits and Twitter. And check out our YouTube channel for in-depth video content! 📲

Help us deliver the best content possible by completing this brief survey. 📝

Email me (Tom Bruni) your feedback; I’d love to hear from you. 📧

Want to sponsor this newsletter and reach hundreds of thousands of passionate investors and traders? Reach us here. 

Terms & Conditions 📝

Securities Disclaimer: STOCKTWITS IS NOT A TAX ADVISOR, BROKER, FINANCIAL ADVISOR OR INVESTMENT ADVISOR. THE SERVICE IS NOT INTENDED TO PROVIDE TAX, LEGAL, FINANCIAL OR INVESTMENT ADVICE, AND NOTHING ON THE SERVICE SHOULD BE CONSTRUED AS AN OFFER TO SELL, A SOLICITATION OF AN OFFER TO BUY, OR A RECOMMENDATION FOR ANY SECURITY. Trading in such securities can result in immediate and substantial losses of the capital invested. You should only invest risk capital, and not capital required for other purposes. You alone are solely responsible for determining whether any investment, security or strategy, or any other product or service, is appropriate or suitable for you based on your investment objectives and personal and financial situation. You should also consult an attorney or tax professional regarding your specific legal or tax situation. The Content is to be used for informational and entertainment purposes only and the Service does not provide investment advice for any individual. Stocktwits, its affiliates and partners specifically disclaim any and all liability or loss arising out of any action taken in reliance on Content, including but not limited to market value or other loss on the sale or purchase of any company, property, product, service, security, instrument, or any other matter. You understand that an investment in any security is subject to a number of risks, and that discussions of any security published on the Service will not contain a list or description of relevant risk factors. In addition, please note that some of the stocks about which Content is published on the Service have a low market capitalization and/or insufficient public float. Such stocks are subject to more risk than stocks of larger companies, including greater volatility, lower liquidity and less publicly available information. Read the full terms & conditions here. 🔍

Author Disclosure: The author of this newsletter does not hold positions in any of the securities or assets mentioned. 📋





Want the latest?

Sign up for Tom Bruni's Newsletter below:


Subscribe Here